Stop Guessing. Start Playing Better.

A simple guide to finding a pickleball paddle that actually fits your style

Hey Picklebackers! 🏓✨

Choosing a pickleball paddle can feel a lot like choosing a new car—everyone has an opinion, specs sound impressive, and somehow the most expensive option still might not be right for you. The truth? The best paddle isn’t the one trending on Instagram or hanging on the pro shop wall. It’s the one that actually fits your game. Before you buy based on buzzwords and endorsements, here’s how to figure out what really matters.

How to Determine the Right Pickleball Paddle for You

If pickleball has taught us anything, it’s that the “best” paddle on the market might be the worst paddle for your game. Walk into any pro shop or scroll through social media and you’ll see endless options—power paddles, control paddles, carbon fiber faces, elongated shapes, hybrid cores. It’s enough to make your head spin.

The truth is, choosing the right pickleball paddle isn’t about hype or price tags. It’s about understanding your game, your strengths, your weaknesses, and what you want the paddle to help you do better. Let’s break it down in a simple, practical way.

1. Start With Your Skill Level and Playing Style

Before worrying about materials or shapes, ask yourself one honest question: How do I win points?

  • Beginner to early intermediate players often benefit from paddles that emphasize forgiveness and control. If you’re still working on consistent contact, soft hands at the net, and keeping balls in play, a high-powered paddle can actually hurt your progress.

  • Intermediate to advanced players usually have repeatable mechanics and can take advantage of paddles designed for spin, precision, or added pop.

Also consider whether you’re:

  • A control-oriented dinker who thrives at the kitchen

  • A baseline grinder who likes deep drives and topspin

  • A banger who looks to speed up and finish points

Your paddle should support your style—not force you to change it.

2. Paddle Weight: Heavier Isn’t Always Better

Weight is one of the most important—and overlooked—factors.

  • Light paddles (7.0–7.5 oz): Easier on the arm, quicker at the net, great for hand battles. However, they can feel unstable on hard shots.

  • Midweight paddles (7.6–8.2 oz): The sweet spot for most players. Balanced power, control, and stability.

  • Heavy paddles (8.3+ oz): More plow-through and power, but can cause fatigue or elbow issues if you’re not careful.

If you play long sessions or struggle with tennis elbow, err on the lighter side. You can always add lead tape later—but you can’t remove weight from a paddle that’s too heavy.

3. Shape Matters More Than You Think

Paddle shape directly affects reach, sweet spot size, and forgiveness.

  • Standard (wide-body) paddles offer the largest sweet spot and are ideal for consistency-focused players.

  • Elongated paddles provide extra reach and leverage for power and spin, but the sweet spot is smaller.

  • Hybrid shapes aim to blend the best of both worlds and are increasingly popular among intermediate players.

If you miss hits off-center or play a lot of fast exchanges at the kitchen, a wider face may save you more points than extra reach ever will.

4. Face Material and Feel

Modern paddles mostly fall into a few categories:

  • Fiberglass faces: More pop and power, softer feel, great for players who need help generating pace.

  • Carbon fiber (raw carbon) faces: Excellent control, spin, and touch. Favored by advanced players who create their own power.

  • Composite blends: Balanced options that sit between fiberglass and carbon fiber.

If you rely on touch shots, resets, and dinks, carbon fiber is usually the safer choice. If you’re struggling to hit through opponents, fiberglass can give you a boost.

5. Core Thickness: Control vs. Power

Most paddles have either a 13–14mm core or a 16mm core.

  • Thinner cores (13–14mm): More pop, faster ball speed, less forgiveness.

  • Thicker cores (16mm): Softer feel, better control, improved blocking and resets.

For most recreational and tournament players, a thicker core offers better all-around performance—especially in the soft game.

6. Grip Size and Comfort

Grip size doesn’t get enough attention, but it matters for both performance and injury prevention.

  • Smaller grips allow more wrist action and spin.

  • Larger grips provide stability and reduce strain.

A good rule of thumb: you should be able to fit your index finger comfortably between your palm and fingers when holding the paddle. When in doubt, go slightly smaller—you can always build it up with overgrips.

7. Demo Before You Commit

No spec sheet replaces real court time. If possible:

  • Demo paddles at your local club

  • Borrow from friends

  • Use retailer demo programs

Pay attention to how the paddle feels on dinks, resets, blocks, and serves, not just put-away shots. The right paddle should feel like an extension of your arm—not something you’re fighting.

@pickleball.benjohns

Choosing the Right Paddle Key Factors #pickleball #benjohns #PPA #pickleballtips

At the end of the day, pickleball is about consistency, confidence, and enjoying the game. The right paddle won’t magically fix everything—but it will support your strengths and make improvement easier. Choose thoughtfully, trust what feels right in your hands, and remember: the best paddle is the one that lets you play freely and have fun out there.

Happy hitting. 🏓

Dill-lighfully yours,
Your PICKLEBACKCLUB Team 🥒🎾

Check out our previous posts…